Severity
Moderate
ModerateActive
CPSC recall · Reported February 19, 2009
Old Navy Recalls Stuffed Toys; Button Eyes Can Detach and Pose a Choking Hazard to Young Children
The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young children.
Compiled from official public sources by the editorial team.
Verify with CPSC →
Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif. recalled The stuffed animal and creature toys are made out of cotton and have plastic button eyes.… - a moderate-severity action.
Old Navy Recalls Stuffed Toys; Button Eyes Can Detach and Pose a Choking Hazard to Young … was recalled by Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif. in February 19, 2009. Reason: The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young childr…. Remedy: Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and r…. Verify recall #09134 with the CPSC before acting.
The recall
Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif. issued this moderate-severity CPSC recall-The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young childr….
- Moderate
- severity level
- February 19, 2009
- reported
Sourced from official CPSC enforcement records. Verify recall #09134 with the agency before acting. Full product description, hazard, remedy, and related recalls are below.
Recall Insight
This CPSC action (record #09134) was formally reported on February 19, 2009. It is classified under Moderate severity, with a current status of Active. Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif. is listed as the recalling firm. Federal records list the affected scope as About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada.
The documented reason for this recall is: The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young children. Distribution information was not included in the agency filing, so consumers should assume broad potential exposure until the firm publishes point-of-sale details. The remedy documented by the agency is: Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a full refund. If purchased online, contact Old Navy for instructions on re… - consumers holding this product should act on that instruction rather than relying on general guidance.
Within the same product category the archive holds 6 closely related recalls, 6 from CPSC - clustering in a narrow category often points to a systemic quality-control or supplier issue rather than a one-off defect. Always verify the recall number against the official agency record before acting.
Children & Baby Products recalls over time
Where this recall sits in its category - 3,731 children & baby products recalls on record
Of 101,704 recalls in the database, 24,878 are high severity, 72,426 moderate, and 4,400 low. This recall is classified moderate severity.
Counts reflect market size and reporting activity, not inherent danger, we do not rank products by risk from raw recall volume.
Affected scope
About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada
Related Recalls
6
6 from same agency
Product description
The stuffed animal and creature toys are made out of cotton and have plastic button eyes. They come in a variety of styles, such as a rabbit, penguin and reindeer. The recalled toys and style numbers are listed below: Type of Stuffed Toy Style Number Brown Plaid Creature (Stubby Stuberson) 612756 Pink Striped Dove 600571 Gray Dog 600572 Hot Pink Creature (Lucy Toothy) 612800 White Dog (Dr. Poopsie) 612738 Brown Penguin 612672 Light Pink Rabbit 612671 Brown Reindeer 612728 Dark Pink Rabbit (Honey O'Bunny) 612806 The style number is located on a white label sewn into the side seam of the toy.
Reason for recall
The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young children.
Remedy, what to do
Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a full refund. If purchased online, contact Old Navy for instructions on returning the toy for a full refund. Consumers who return the toy before July 1, 2009 will also receive a $5 coupon toward a future Old Navy purchase.
Recall Profile
| Attribute | Value |
|---|---|
| Agency | U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission |
| Severity class | Moderate |
| Status | Active |
| Recall number | 09134 |
| Date reported | February 19, 2009 |
| Date initiated | February 19, 2009 |
| Recalling firm | Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif. |
| Affected scope | About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada |
| Distribution | Not disclosed |
| Official source | CPSC notice → |
Profile values are sourced directly from the official CPSC enforcement record. Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission.
What to do with this recall
Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a ful…
- Check the recall number (09134) and product description against the item you own. Search the archive
- Confirm the current status and remedy on the official CPSC notice before acting. CPSC notice
- Follow the documented remedy (refund, replacement, repair, or disposal) rather than general advice. What to do next
This page summarizes the official CPSC record for research and awareness; it is not legal, medical, or safety advice. Verify with the issuing agency before acting.
Frequently Asked Questions
What product was recalled? ▼
The stuffed animal and creature toys are made out of cotton and have plastic button eyes. They come in a variety of styles, such as a rabbit, penguin and reindeer. The recalled toys and style numbers are listed below: Type of Stuffed Toy Style Number Brown Plaid Creature (Stubby Stuberson) 612756 Pink Striped Dove 600571 Gray Dog 600572 Hot Pink Creature (Lucy Toothy) 612800 White Dog (Dr. Poopsie) 612738 Brown Penguin 612672 Light Pink Rabbit 612671 Brown Reindeer 612728 Dark Pink Rabbit (Honey O'Bunny) 612806 The style number is located on a white label sewn into the side seam of the toy.. Recalled by Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif.. Units affected: About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada.
Why was this product recalled? ▼
The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young children.
What should consumers do? ▼
Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a full refund. If purchased online, contact Old Navy for instructions on returning the toy for a full refund. Consumers who return the toy before July 1, 2009 will also receive a $5 coupon toward a future Old Navy purchase.
Which agency issued this recall? ▼
This recall was issued by the CPSC on February 19, 2009. Severity: Moderate. Recall number: 09134.
How do I check if my product is affected by a recall? ▼
Check the product description and recall number (09134) against your product. Visit the official CPSC website for the most current information. You can also use our Recall Checker tool to search by product name or brand.
How do I report an injury from a recalled product? ▼
Report injuries to the issuing agency: CPSC at SaferProducts.gov, NHTSA at nhtsa.gov/report-a-safety-problem, or FDA via MedWatch. Document the product (photos, model/serial numbers, purchase receipts) and seek medical attention. Injury reports help agencies track hazard patterns and may strengthen enforcement actions.
Nearby Recalls in This Category
Other recalls in the same product category, useful for spotting patterns across the same defect class or manufacturer.
CPSC Moderate
AMASKY Nursing Pillows Recalled Due to Risk of Serious Injury or Death from Suffocation; Violate Mandatory Standards fo…
Xishentang Dongguan Trading Co, Ltd., dba Pretty-Life, of China · 2026-07-02
CPSC Moderate
Diamond Wipes International Recalls CVS Health Medicated Hemorrhoidal Wipes Due to Risk of Serious Injury or Death from…
Diamond Wipes International, Inc. of Chino, California · 2026-07-02
CPSC Moderate
Junpower CR2032 Lithium Coin Batteries Recalled Due to Risk of Serious Injury or Death from Battery Ingestion Hazard; V…
· 2026-07-02
CPSC Moderate
Target Recalls Gigglescape™ Under the Sea Popping Toy Due to Choking Hazard
· 2026-07-02
CPSC Moderate
Vevor Recalls Baby Loungers Due to Risk of Serious Injury or Death from Entrapment and Fall Hazards; Violate Mandatory …
Sanven Technology Ltd., dba Vevor, of Rancho Cucamonga, California · 2026-07-02
Compare this recall with AMASKY Nursing Pillows Recalled Due to Risk of Serious Inju… →
Every figure on PlainRecalls is rendered directly from official FDA, CPSC and NHTSA recall records, no number is typed in by an editor. This recall: CPSC, reported February 19, 2009. Severity classes follow each agency's own taxonomy (FDA Class I/II/III; CPSC and NHTSA by hazard type), and related-recall context is computed across the full archive. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error. Data current as of July 2026.