Severity
Critical
CriticalClass ITerminated
FDA Food recall · Reported June 24, 2015
Garber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shrink wrap of 3. #1 lot of 211/ 3 pk produced on 12/12/13 expires on 12/12/14 #2 lot of 451/3 pk produced on 3/31/14 expires 3/31/15 #3 lot of 454/3 pk produced on 11/5 14 expires on 11/5/15 1116 (three packs) = 3348 singles
Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (eggs added to cake) (undeclared egg allergen).
Garber Ice Cream Company Inc recalled Garber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shri… - a critical-severity action.
Garber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shri… was recalled by Garber Ice Cream Company Inc in June 24, 2015. Reason: Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (egg…. Check the official notice for the remedy. Verify recall #F-2440-2015 with the FDA Food before acting.
The recall
Garber Ice Cream Company Inc issued this critical-severity FDA Food recall-Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (egg….
- Critical
- severity level
- Class I
- classification
- June 24, 2015
- reported
Sourced from official FDA Food enforcement records. Verify recall #F-2440-2015 with the agency before acting. Full product description, hazard, remedy, and related recalls are below.
Recall Insight
This FDA Food action (record #F-2440-2015) was formally reported on June 24, 2015, with the manufacturer initiating the action on April 13, 2015. It is classified under Critical severity (Class I), with a current status of Terminated. Garber Ice Cream Company Inc is listed as the recalling firm, operating out of Winchester, VA. Federal records list the affected scope as 2427 Distributed. 921 still in house.
The documented reason for this recall is: Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (eggs added to cake) (undeclared egg allergen). Distribution data in the federal record shows the product reached: According to firm the distribution pattern is Virginia, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Maryland. Distribution scope directly affects the consumer exposure window and determines whether a recall remains regional or escalates into a nationwide advisory.
Within the same product category the archive holds 6 closely related recalls, 2 from FDA Food - clustering in a narrow category often points to a systemic quality-control or supplier issue rather than a one-off defect. Always verify the recall number against the official agency record before acting.
Food recalls over time
Where this recall sits in its category - 25,126 food recalls on record
Of 101,704 recalls in the database, 24,878 are high severity, 72,426 moderate, and 4,400 low. This recall is classified high severity.
Counts reflect market size and reporting activity, not inherent danger, we do not rank products by risk from raw recall volume.
Affected scope
2427 Distributed. 921 still in house
Related Recalls
6
2 from same agency
Product description
Garber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shrink wrap of 3. #1 lot of 211/ 3 pk produced on 12/12/13 expires on 12/12/14 #2 lot of 451/3 pk produced on 3/31/14 expires 3/31/15 #3 lot of 454/3 pk produced on 11/5 14 expires on 11/5/15 1116 (three packs) = 3348 singles
Reason for recall
Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (eggs added to cake) (undeclared egg allergen).
Recall Profile
| Attribute | Value |
|---|---|
| Agency | U.S. Food and Drug Administration |
| Severity class | Critical (Class I) |
| Status | Terminated |
| Recall number | F-2440-2015 |
| Date reported | June 24, 2015 |
| Date initiated | April 13, 2015 |
| Recalling firm | Garber Ice Cream Company Inc |
| Firm location | Winchester, VA |
| Affected scope | 2427 Distributed. 921 still in house |
| Distribution | According to firm the distribution pattern is Virginia, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Maryland |
Profile values are sourced directly from the official FDA Food enforcement record. Source: U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
What to do with this recall
Match your product against the recall record, then act on the agency remedy.
- Check the recall number (F-2440-2015) and product description against the item you own. Search the archive
- Confirm the current status with FDA Food before acting, recall details can be updated.
- This is a Class I (high-risk) recall, stop using the product immediately and follow the disposal or return instructions. What to do next
This page summarizes the official FDA Food record for research and awareness; it is not legal, medical, or safety advice. Verify with the issuing agency before acting.
Frequently Asked Questions
What product was recalled? ▼
Garber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shrink wrap of 3. #1 lot of 211/ 3 pk produced on 12/12/13 expires on 12/12/14 #2 lot of 451/3 pk produced on 3/31/14 expires 3/31/15 #3 lot of 454/3 pk produced on 11/5 14 expires on 11/5/15 1116 (three packs) = 3348 singles. Recalled by Garber Ice Cream Company Inc. Units affected: 2427 Distributed. 921 still in house.
Why was this product recalled? ▼
Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (eggs added to cake) (undeclared egg allergen).
Which agency issued this recall? ▼
This recall was issued by the FDA Food on June 24, 2015. Severity: Critical. Recall number: F-2440-2015.
Where was the recalled product distributed? ▼
Distribution: According to firm the distribution pattern is Virginia, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Maryland.
How do I check if my product is affected by a recall? ▼
Check the product description and recall number (F-2440-2015) against your product. Visit the official FDA Food website for the most current information. You can also use our Recall Checker tool to search by product name or brand.
What are the health risks of consuming a recalled food product? ▼
Recalled food products may contain contaminants, undeclared allergens, or harmful bacteria such as Salmonella, Listeria, or E. coli. Consuming these products can cause foodborne illness ranging from mild gastrointestinal symptoms to serious conditions requiring hospitalization. If you have consumed a recalled food product and experience symptoms, contact your healthcare provider and report to the FDA via MedWatch.
Nearby Recalls in This Category
Other recalls in the same product category, useful for spotting patterns across the same defect class or manufacturer.
CPSC Moderate
Conair Recalls Over One Million Cuisinart Grill Brushes Due to Ingestion Hazard
· 2026-07-02
CPSC Moderate
Montessori Busy Board Toys Recalled Due to Risk of Serious Injury or Death from Magnet Ingestion; Violate Mandatory Sta…
Lesonic Technology Co., Ltd., dba Small Fish, of China · 2026-06-25
CPSC Moderate
Bada Boom Fireworks Recalls Pyro Diablo "Diablo Rising" Fireworks Due to Risk of Serious Injury or Death from Explosion…
· 2026-06-18
CPSC Moderate
Yamaha Recalls UMAX Bistro and Bistro Deluxe Vehicles Due to Injury Hazard
· 2026-06-11
FDA Food Critical
Butter Parsley Bagel Crisps, Item Number 18490, Net Weight: 10 lbs. Legacy Bakehouse, LLC, N8W22100 Johnson Dr., Wauk…
Legacy Bakehouse LLC · 2026-06-03
Compare this recall with Conair Recalls Over One Million Cuisinart Grill Brushes Due… →
Every figure on PlainRecalls is rendered directly from official FDA, CPSC and NHTSA recall records, no number is typed in by an editor. This recall: FDA Food, reported June 24, 2015. Severity classes follow each agency's own taxonomy (FDA Class I/II/III; CPSC and NHTSA by hazard type), and related-recall context is computed across the full archive. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error. Data current as of July 2026.